by Chinky420 » Wed Dec 03, 2008 12:30 pm
if you take pictures, maybe we can figure out what the cheap method is that they are using to be able to lowball the work like that.
i say this because you describe it as a big, round, clean dent, which to me, means that there won't have to be any re-painting, and that the dent only has to be popped back out and it'll look alright.
if that's the case, then it could be that they plan on just using a gimmicky method, like using hot and cold to make it pop itself out, or by using some sort of brace to pop out the middle of the dent, so it's back to where it should be.
if you're worried about the job getting done right, with out the possibility of having complications delay the readiness of your car, then get it done professionally.
if you are looking to save some money, and can afford to deal with jackassess who may be able to fix it back to OEM (or may not), who may mess up your paint, who may not even be able to paint match it (if they end up chipping the paint), then go with the shady guys. because i'm willing to bet that the 500-800 is for a basic attempt at dent repair, and probably won't guarentee the workmanship.
now if these guys are coming from another shop, and they have the facilities to be able to pull panels, hammer them out, sandblast, mix paint, and primer and paint, then go for it. at that point, even if they mess it up, they have the resources to be able to fix it.
but if they're working out of their own garage at home, then it's not worth it, IMO.